Per serving, worked out from the ingredient table. Grandma's way is the starting point the other versions are compared with.
Ingredients
Besan (chickpea flour, gram flour)⅓ cup
Cooking oil (vegetable oil)3 tbsp
Cumin seeds½ tsp
Fenugreek seeds¼ tsp
Asafoetidaa pinch
Curry leaves1 sprig
Green chilli2, slit
Ginger2.5 cm, grated
Turmeric (ground turmeric)½ tsp
Red chilli powder (indian red chili powder)¾ tsp
Tamarindsmall lemon sized ball
Waterabout 5 1/2 cups
Tomato2, chopped
Potato1 large, cubed
Drumstick (moringa pods)2, cut in 6 cm pieces
Cluster beans (guar beans)a handful, trimmed
Okra (lady's finger)8, halved
Carrot1, cubed
Macaroni½ cup small pasta
Saltto taste
Coriander leaves (cilantro)a handful
Parmesanto finish, optional
Method
7 steps
1Soak the tamarind in 100 ml hot water and squeeze out the pulp.
2Fry the okra in 1 tbsp oil on medium heat until no longer sticky. Set aside.
3Heat the rest of the oil. Add cumin, fenugreek, asafoetida, curry leaves, ginger and chilli. Add the besan and roast on low, stirring, for 6 to 8 minutes.
4Whisk in the water gradually, then add turmeric, chilli powder and tomato. Boil, then simmer 10 minutes.
5Add the potato, carrot, drumstick and cluster beans and simmer 12 minutes.
6Add the pasta and okra and simmer 8 minutes. Stir in the tamarind and salt and cook 2 more minutes.
7Serve hot with coriander and a little grated parmesan if you like.
Serve it like this
Ladle into a deep bowl so a drumstick piece stands up, scatter coriander and add a little cheese at the table.